- Jan 7, 2009
- 17,094
- 22,286
Come on Jof, give it the long handle.
There is absolutely no justification to continually pick Buttler after this test. All it would do is prove that Root has his boy club and Buttler is a fully subscribed member of it.
The argument that Foakes has done nothing at county level is futile, too. All of these players are on a blank slate in that regard and, quite frankly, Buttler has done fuck all in any extended format of the game for a very, very long time.
Unfortunately for Foakes, if the impossible happens and Buttler is dropped, it’ll be his mate from Yorkshire who takes his place.
Ah you’re absolutely correct. Bairstow was in the ODI bubble.if you're referring to Bairstow - he's not in the squad.
Foakes is the only official back-up keeper in the squad, although Bracey is also a keeper.
Sadly, this is the crux of it.Ah you’re absolutely correct. Bairstow was in the ODI bubble.
This just means Buttler won’t be dropped then!
He certainly relaxed. Silly **** forgot to put his bat & pad together. Pretty loose, airy fairy shot
Still a good 38. Should be good for another 12/18 months....
I suppose he should have hit it, but Atherton / Warne / Hussein said there wasn't much he could do about it. It just went straight when the spin didn't spin.
?????
Yeah he was unlucky again ffs
I forgot a couple
He played for the spin and it went straight
He played through the line and the ball moved
Only hope is that Riswan has been so fantastic and shown Buttler up so much behind the stumps that they finally give in and play their best keeper as keeper!!
Going all matchday thread for a moment.......He was picked to bowl fast. Bowl fast or fuck off.The only thing I'll back Root on is the Archer conundrum, and it is one lets be honest. He's gone from bowling 96mph to 86mph and basically said it's his choice/limit. That actually must be quite frustrating for Root.
Wood would be more reliable if he wasn't made of glass.
Silverwood and Root got there side very wrong for this test.. We simply aren't good enough to go in a batter short!
Going all matchday thread for a moment.......He was picked to bowl fast. Bowl fast or fuck off.
Don't let Ed Smith off the hook!Silverwood and Root got there side very wrong for this test.. We simply aren't good enough to go in a batter short!
True but West Indies are mouse compared to this Pakistan side.Same team that beat the Windies last match.
Broad should have had it over Root in the first placeLooking forward to the day Root gives up the captaincy (they'll never sack him in a million)
If that day were today, who would you pick?
No way i'd give it to Stokes and risk losing his form/ability, not to mention doing it 'his way' against the Windies wasn't exactly a resounding endorsement of his ability to do the job.
Do we pick the best English county captain and do a Brearley? Candidates seem a bit thin on the ground to me
Christ almighty...Broad should have had it over Root in the first place
*shuddersBroad should have had it over Root in the first place
hahaIn his interview with Michael Atherton last night Archer apparently said “It wasn’t really the conditions to bowl fast...”