What's new

The beginning of the end...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Metalhead

But that's a debate for another thread.....
Nov 24, 2013
25,491
38,611
Possibly answered your own question mate.

Frustration turning to a lack of enthusiasm from Poch?

He's rightly lauded for doing so well and then doesn't feel he's appreciated enough because we havnt adapted to keep him happy - in some respects?

Speculating but I'm guessing that's the thrust of it.
Who knows. One thing's for sure though, with Poch having been just provided with three new players at not inconsiderable expense, it's a bit early for anyone to be talking about him leaving.
 

JayB

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2011
6,667
26,110
What it comes down to for me is that IMO last season's awful form was primarily a product of the disgracefully threadbare squad which had been heavily fatigued by the world cup, could not be rotated much over the course of the season, and eventually succumbed to a genuine injury crisis. The players were completely and utterly knackered by the end of the season but they didn't suddenly become shit.

By and large we've fixed the underlying issue now with the signings of Ndombele and GLC. We've got real squad depth in CM which has the knock-on effect of bolstering our squad depth in attack because it means the likes of Eriksen and Dele should not have to be moved out of their natural positions to paper over the cracks.

The problem is that we've yet to integrate those new signings fully and have had a rash of injuries and players affected by the European transfer window. It's still very, very early in the season and both of those problems ought to take care of themselves first with the closure of the window, secondly with those who have been injured or suspended being restored to the side and getting up to speed, and finally with Ndombele and GLC being integrated.

This squad has dramatically more to offer than what we've seen in the first few matches of the season, which have been rocked by tumult largely outside of Poch's control.
 

wrd

Well-Known Member
Aug 22, 2014
13,603
58,005
I dont think anybody is happy with the result yesterday. Some of us are just disagreeing with the premise of the original post - that it proves Poch is done here.

I'd hate to think he's done here, I think that yesterday was the moment that the paper over the cracks has finally worn thin and things have to change but I hope Poch is the one that incites that change.
 

Thewobbler

Well-Known Member
Oct 29, 2016
3,814
5,701
I posted in the utd thread that the fans had turned on them already after 3 games and the wheels had fallen off, and now we are here with this thread.

Poch has finally got his players in, the ones he wanted. Lets just wait and see what happens when he has them all on the pitch together. Lets see where we are at when the international break comes around. Hopefully most players will back this weekend and we can get a winning run started.
 

Spurs_S.A.

Well-Known Member
Apr 29, 2018
164
271
If what ValenciaYid is saying is true with regards to him losing the dressing room, I actually wonder whether decisions in the final were not perceived well by the team and those within the squad were not happy to see Kane get preferential treatment over Moura. I'm not suggesting that's the case but certainly I could understand that causing problems.

Was thinking the exact same thing, Kane claiming that goal in April 2018 might possibly have started this and the CL Final must off topped it off. Just theory off course.
 

hatch

Well-Known Member
Apr 4, 2005
402
509
With MP saying this is the “most unsettled squad” he’s worked with, what happens if the unsettled players don’t get their move or they wait to January. Can you see the situation getting any better?

There is certainly something not right but I’m not sure it’s due to “unsettled” players.
 

Primativ

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2017
3,229
12,486
It hasn’t been great for a while but the general consensus at the start of last year was that those above Poch let him down with a complete lack of investment and ambition. Most people thought we would stagnate and struggle last year. It was only our ability to cobble a lot of results until February that people forget how stale our squad had become. It’s gonna take a lot longer than three games to fix that especially as a lot of things are still up in the air and the new signings arent really up and running yet. Personally I think we should have done more this summer too.


You're acting like Poch has taken over a team battling relegation? we have a really strong squad, you seem to think it's acceptable that we've been so poor because of various reasons, but I completely disagree. We continually lost games last season against vastly inferior opposition, we are hardly a cobbled together shadow of a squad that Poch is turd polishing.
 

fortworthspur

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2007
11,250
17,554
With MP saying this is the “most unsettled squad” he’s worked with, what happens if the unsettled players don’t get their move or they wait to January. Can you see the situation getting any better?

There is certainly something not right but I’m not sure it’s due to “unsettled” players.

have we even had any offers for any of them? not sure its the club's fault. We DID block Modric and he came back and performed like a professional.
 

Mr Pink

SC Supporter
Aug 25, 2010
55,367
100,858
Let's just hope some of the issues behind the scenes get sorted, and Poch gets us going again.

That's the best outcome by far.
 

SpursSince1980

Well-Known Member
Jan 23, 2011
4,757
14,493
It comes down to yesterday because it would seem we are still having bad games like last season...if we cant solve these problems then there will be no trophies...surely the idea is to do better not the same or worse....
This is the uber point that I'd like to think the vast majority on here agree with. We rode our luck last year. We were ineffective in many, many games. Not just the last fifteen.

The main difference was that we somehow were managing to win those other games. But I wouldn't say there was a massive gulf in our overall effectiveness during the course of the season. Some better games. Some better halves than others.

But, by-and-large, I think our performances were fairly consistent. The one plus, is that we were able to grind out some results, and to our benefit those who'd challenge us for a top 4 place, were frackin' awful over the last five or six games of the season.

So, this isn't about losing to Newcastle. This is about feeling frustrated and annoyed. Feeling let down. Because, if you agree that last year was a tough slog, then you probably hoped you'd see a team emerge from the outset, that were simply playing better. That's not been the case. It's been more of the same. And if not for a few timely moments, here and there, plus a bit of luck, we'd be looking at 0 points from 3 games. And that would be shocking, but not unreasonable given what we've seen so far.
 

rossdapep

Well-Known Member
Aug 25, 2011
22,360
80,561
The fall started with selling Walker. Not saying we shouldn't have, but that felt like a big moment. Especially as it completely changed our whole way of playing. We've played horrible football for the most part for the last 2 seasons. When was the last time you watched spurs (against anyone half decent) and went "wow, that was incredible"?

The last season at the lane was the last time for me. Since then it's been mostly shite. Despite getting results, the football has been rubbish
If Poch got rid of Walker because he was angling for a move behind his back then I completely support him on that.
If he got rid because Walker had the hump and Poch decided he'd passed his best than that is a huge worry. (Didn't he say that?)

I know Poch is about the collective and I'm with him on that but sometimes you've got to let some things slide.
 

robertgoulet

SC Resident Crooner Extraordinaire
Jul 23, 2013
3,610
12,552
So for all the players we have and dont have we should expect to lose to Newcastle....

I think you could look at the match as it played out (Kane penalty, Son possible penalty), xG, etc... and say if we played that exact same way 10 times we'd have won 7-8 times.

Should we have played better? Hell yes. But we could play that same game with the same team and same subs over and over and again and expect the outcome to be different more often than not.

There are issues that need fixing but the doom and gloom is wild.
 

stevenurse

Palacios' neck fat
May 14, 2007
6,089
10,022
Just out of interest, when would your patience run out? What would have to happen?
We didn't struggle against Villa. We absolutely dominated them from start to finish.

And we dominated Newcastle too. It wasn't effort lacking it was inspiration. That is as much down to Poch's team selection I suppose but not evidence of players "not playing for him".

In that time we've also got results against City and some European giants.

Once we're injury free we can assess. But I can't be the only one perturbed by how easily we are torching a manager who has got us to where we are.

Maybe it's the supporters letting the team down. There was no "12th man" at WHL yesterday. Can't imagine what Lo celso made of it...

If you saw 'domination' against Villa and Newcastle then that's an issue. Heaton made what 1 decent save against us, and Ndombele scored from the resulting rebound. Domination for me would be a team hanging on and their keeper having a worldy. Newcastle were more than happy to take a point, so having 80% of the ball means fuck all. They didn't want it. It became attack v defence after they scored, and their defence dominated our attack. Possession % and number of passes are by no metric a barometer of domination. They could have easily scored one or two more than us based on the chances they had. Considering they got into our half about 6 times all game that's very concerning
 

scat1620

L'espion mal fait
May 11, 2008
16,410
52,995
We didn't struggle against Villa. We absolutely dominated them from start to finish.

And we dominated Newcastle too. It wasn't effort lacking it was inspiration.
Massive disagree on this point from me. IMO, dominating a football match requires inspiration and chance creation in addition to having the majority of the possession. Having all of the ball but still looking less likely to score than the other team is not domination in a football game as I see it.
 

Mr Pink

SC Supporter
Aug 25, 2010
55,367
100,858
Massive disagree on this point from me. IMO, dominating a football match requires inspiration and chance creation in addition to having the majority of the possession. Having all of the ball but still looking less likely to score than the other team is not domination in a football game as I see it.

I thought we were poor against Villa until the first goal flew in. They were troubling us more I felt.
 

Thewobbler

Well-Known Member
Oct 29, 2016
3,814
5,701
If Poch got rid of Walker because he was angling for a move behind his back then I completely support him on that.
If he got rid because Walker had the hump and Poch decided he'd passed his best than that is a huge worry. (Didn't he say that?)

I know Poch is about the collective and I'm with him on that but sometimes you've got to let some things slide.

Didnt walker have the hump because he was getting rotated a lot and missing some big games? Could be bullshit and Ive just made that up.
 

hatch

Well-Known Member
Apr 4, 2005
402
509
have we even had any offers for any of them? not sure its the club's fault. We DID block Modric and he came back and performed like a professional.
Certainly not blaming the club. I was just curious that the “unsettled” squad was just a side dish. In my opinion it runs deeper than that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top