What's new

Ratings vs Watford

MOTM

  • Lloris

    Votes: 1 0.3%
  • Trippier

    Votes: 274 69.9%
  • Toby

    Votes: 7 1.8%
  • Rimmer

    Votes: 7 1.8%
  • Davies

    Votes: 26 6.6%
  • Dier

    Votes: 4 1.0%
  • Dembele

    Votes: 30 7.7%
  • Lamela

    Votes: 4 1.0%
  • Eriksen

    Votes: 32 8.2%
  • Chadli

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kane

    Votes: 1 0.3%
  • Alli

    Votes: 5 1.3%
  • Son

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Carroll

    Votes: 1 0.3%

  • Total voters
    392

Archibald&Crooks

Aegina Expat
Admin
Feb 1, 2005
55,630
205,450
When we played Watford away Alan Shearer said:

“Because of the three at the back, it enabled Trippier to virtually play as a right winger and he did it unbelievably well,” he said. “He gave them width in the first half”

Last night he repeated that almost word for word and included Davies as well. Yesterday we might well have seen a glimpse of the future, both could easily become first choices before much longer.
 

JimmyG2

SC Supporter
Dec 7, 2006
15,014
20,779
When we played Watford away Alan Shearer said:

“Because of the three at the back, it enabled Trippier to virtually play as a right winger and he did it unbelievably well,” he said. “He gave them width in the first half”

Last night he repeated that almost word for word and included Davies as well. Yesterday we might well have seen a glimpse of the future, both could easily become first choices before much longer.

Think Pochettino will continue to rotate his players at full back
and not make final first choice preferences.
If he analyses and monitors the opposition closely as reported
it will be horses for courses.
Each of them has positive and negative facets.
Trippier and Davies are slow to turn when defending
and could be caught out playing so far upfield.
Both played exceptionally well yesterday though.
but against speedy wingers Rose and Walker might be preferred
 

mckenz

Well-Known Member
Jan 27, 2011
967
2,355
When we played Watford away Alan Shearer said:

“Because of the three at the back, it enabled Trippier to virtually play as a right winger and he did it unbelievably well,” he said. “He gave them width in the first half”

Last night he repeated that almost word for word and included Davies as well. Yesterday we might well have seen a glimpse of the future, both could easily become first choices before much longer.



nah, Shearers way too old to be an automatic first choice.....
 

oohaahedgar

Well-Known Member
Aug 8, 2005
877
1,718
When we played Watford away Alan Shearer said:

“Because of the three at the back, it enabled Trippier to virtually play as a right winger and he did it unbelievably well,” he said. “He gave them width in the first half”

Last night he repeated that almost word for word and included Davies as well. Yesterday we might well have seen a glimpse of the future, both could easily become first choices before much longer.
Possibly but that would be very harsh on the other two. I thought walker was almost our best player against Norwich. Have we ever had 4 fullbacks as good as now? Don't think so.
 

Archibald&Crooks

Aegina Expat
Admin
Feb 1, 2005
55,630
205,450
Possibly but that would be very harsh on the other two. I thought walker was almost our best player against Norwich. Have we ever had 4 fullbacks as good as now? Don't think so.
Oh I agree, I just think, (as you say) its possible. Time will tell.
 

Ironskullll

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2010
1,378
1,894
Watford came to defend and did it really well, backed by a new kind of Gomes. I had already noted the total absence of Watford fans moaning this season about his poor concentration, flapping at crosses and fumbling of easy shots. Nor had I seen any mocking comments in the press. Gomes without the daft mistakes is one hell of a goalkeeper. And he seems at last to have erased those wayward moments from his repertoire. But he wasn't quite good enough to prevent us from winning the match, even with assistance from the referee.

So many times we have heard the WHL crowd becoming ratty and unsupportive when we have dominated the first 45-60 minutes of a game without reward. That didn't remotely happen yesterday and it had to be because of the sheer quality of the play. In the first half, we appeared shot-shy, but that wasn't really because we weren't shooting, it was because Watford's defenders closed down relentlessly and blocked or deflected a large proportion of our shots. But we were even more relentless, swarming all over them in midfield from about minute 3 until very late in the game. We were first to nearly every ball and we out-pressed opponents who were attempting the same kind of high-pressing midfield game that we use.

The result was a game that was high on intensity, but not always high on continuity. When we did manage to string a move together it was, perforce, a beautiful network of one-touch passes and layoffs, because nothing else would penetrate Watford's determination. It was a great spectacle, nerve-racking yet rewarding, frustrating and ultimately successful.

Lloris - 6.5 So little to do. DId it.

Trippier - 8.5 If we have a walking tribute to Pochettino's abilities to improve a player, Kieran is that man.When he arrived, he looked seriously out of his depth: positionally unreliable, slow and prone to lunging. Fast forward a few months and he is adopting positions that adjust for his lack of pace, getting involved in everything and raining in terrifying and unplayable crosses. I can't choose a MotM today between 4 players, but he's one of the candidates.

Alderweireld - 7 The usual commanding and controlling performance. I see some comemnts that he had little to do, but the reason that Ighalo (and Deeney) did so little was because Alderweireld, Wimmer and Dier marshalled them so well.

Wimmer - 7 Similar to Toby. Calm, controlling and reliable.

Davies - 8 Another MotM candidate, just inspiring in the first half, where he put himself through on goal three times by way of strength and wit. Won the ball and passed well throughout the match. Less influential after half time.

Dier - 6.5 We can't do this without Eric. The whole approach only works because he's posted in front of the defence,using his strength, judgment and mobility to keep the pressure off us and on the opposition.

Dembele - 8.5 A third MotM, not only dominating midfield with power and skill, but also acting as the key man in the move that led to the goal.

Lamela - 6.5 There was little flashy from Erik yesterday, but a hell of a lot of closing down, pressing, tackling and running. Team player, not luxury star.

Eriksen - 8 The 4th MotM. Central to absolutely everything, passing with vision, running a bloody marathon, closing down like a mad person and making things happen wherever he popped up, which was everywhere. Had we shot more accurately or played against a goalkeeper less in form, Eriksen could have collected a handful of assists.

Chadli - 6 Good without making a big impression. Played his part.

Kane - 6.5 The ball wouldn't run for him in front of goal (and Watford's defence made his life very difficult), but Kane was involved in most of our best moves and held the ball up all over the pitch.


Alli - 7.5 The young man has a gift for making the difference.

Son - 6 A mixture of sparkling runs and clumsy first touches. As others have observed, Son seems to be more effective when he starts than as an impact substitute.

Carroll - NET


The team - 10 It's a team. It plays as a team. It uses teamwork to dominate the opposition.
I seldom disagree with anything you post but I really did think that Gomes rode his luck yesterday. For me, he frequently palmed and punched when he might have caught, and the ricochets that arose were pretty random - he was just fortunate in the way they dropped. And he still had that look and of a frightened rabbit. At least, that's how I saw it :)
 

Flashspur

Well-Known Member
Jul 28, 2012
6,883
9,069
When we played Watford away Alan Shearer said:

“Because of the three at the back, it enabled Trippier to virtually play as a right winger and he did it unbelievably well,” he said. “He gave them width in the first half”

Last night he repeated that almost word for word and included Davies as well. Yesterday we might well have seen a glimpse of the future, both could easily become first choices before much longer.

yes interesting take on Davies and Frodo in the Fourfourtwo website article below plus an all round excellent break down of tactics

http://www.fourfourtwo.com/features...king-points-spurs-1-0-watford#:XUOPKpx0qwRPzA
 

TaoistMonkey

Welcome! Everything is fine.
Staff
Oct 25, 2005
32,629
33,579
I'll just leave this here...

Me to Gooner at work: I caught the second half of the Arsenal game and I haven't see such a poor match. Arsenal could barely string two passes together.

Gooner:: What about your lot. Lucky with a 1:0 struggling against Watford.

Me: *Face palm*
 

Chris12

Well-Known Member
Mar 6, 2013
7,293
13,252
Just goes to show how much people base their opinion because of the media. Watford were lucking not to lose 3-0, we peppered them and they did fuck all
 

double0

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2006
14,423
12,258
I'll just leave this here...

Me to Gooner at work: I caught the second half of the Arsenal game and I haven't see such a poor match. Arsenal could barely string two passes together.

Gooner:: What about your lot. Lucky with a 1:0 struggling against Watford.

Me: *Face palm*

What did you expect back. I suggest you just keep it quiet there's still a long way to go.
 

mark87

Well-Known Member
Nov 29, 2004
36,269
115,392
I'll just leave this here...

Me to Gooner at work: I caught the second half of the Arsenal game and I haven't see such a poor match. Arsenal could barely string two passes together.

Gooner:: What about your lot. Lucky with a 1:0 struggling against Watford.

Me: *Face palm*

Tbf he's right, we are lucky that not one of their 3 shots were on target.
 

Bus-Conductor

SC Supporter
Oct 19, 2004
39,837
50,713
Good overview. I'm glad Alli is finally getting your recognition.

Disagree about playing Mason though. Dier allows Dembele to get further up the pitch where he is an integral part of our pressing . Take him out and Dembele will be the one playing in front of our back 4 which would be a waste. And how can Dembele be left out ? We look much weaker without him. Mason however adds another very good option for squad rotation in the cups.

Don't really get the Alli comment. I have continually acknowledged Alli's good attributes, just unlike you, and some others, haven't closed my eyes to his weaknesses as well.

I still think he's a player ( like others I have used as high profile examples frequently like Yaya, Pogba etc)) who despite clearly being very talented isn't the easiest to fit into a 4231 system.

It's worth noting that we played well before he came on and created chances and with better finishing from Davies or Kane would have already been leading.

I don't think this team succeeds or fails because of any one player, even Kane. I think this team will graft out performances and hopefully results no matter who plays, what matters most is that we stick to the ethos and not the individual.
 

dannythomas

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2004
3,758
2,813
Don't really get the Alli comment. I have continually acknowledged Alli's good attributes, just unlike you, and some others, haven't closed my eyes to his weaknesses as well.

I still think he's a player ( like others I have used as high profile examples frequently like Yaya, Pogba etc)) who despite clearly being very talented isn't the easiest to fit into a 4231 system.

It's worth noting that we played well before he came on and created chances and with better finishing from Davies or Kane would have already been leading.

I don't think this team succeeds or fails because of any one player, even Kane. I think this team will graft out performances and hopefully results no matter who plays, what matters most is that we stick to the ethos and not the individual.

I think if you read back through your ratings posts your comments about Alli until the last 2 games have been largely negative advocating his omission.

Of course , he is only 19 and obviously still has a lot to learn. But his contribution to the team has been phenomenal. If he is struggling to fit into our system then I wonder how great he would be if we actually played a system that suits him ?
 

Bus-Conductor

SC Supporter
Oct 19, 2004
39,837
50,713
I think if you read back through your ratings posts your comments about Alli until the last 2 games have been largely negative advocating his omission.

Of course , he is only 19 and obviously still has a lot to learn. But his contribution to the team has been phenomenal. If he is struggling to fit into our system then I wonder how great he would be if we actually played a system that suits him ?


His contribution in many ways has been similar to that of Chadli's last season and no-one thought it outrageous to call what he did some of the time when he wasn't scoring and assisting poor, so why is there a different rule for Alli ?

He's provided some superb moments, he clearly has ability - I've constantly acknowledged this - he's also very young and has massive scope - I've repeatedly acknowledged this too - but he's also put in some pretty poor overall performances and often been played in roles that don't really suit him or the dynamic of the team - and I stand by this evaluation too. I've never said he's shit lets drop him forever, I've constantly suggested that I'd like us to try a 433, because I think it would accommodate him better.

I like Alli, apart from ability, I think he's got real character and pitch presence, but I still care more about the balance and dynamics of the team more than I ever will about any individual. I keep using this example but it's a great current one, ManC are woefully under achieving because IMO Pellegrini is trying shoehorn Yaya into a CM2 - 4231 format. Juventus are achieving good things (including beating ManY away) because they aren't doing the same with Pogba.

There's always been an oversensitivity in this place to criticism of favourites, whilst those that aren't are fair game to be pilloried to buggery.
 

thinktank

Hmmm...
Sep 28, 2004
45,893
68,893
When we played Watford away Alan Shearer said:

“Because of the three at the back, it enabled Trippier to virtually play as a right winger and he did it unbelievably well,” he said. “He gave them width in the first half”

Last night he repeated that almost word for word and included Davies as well. Yesterday we might well have seen a glimpse of the future, both could easily become first choices before much longer.
If it's obvious to a good few of us on here it will not have escaped poch who relies on FBs heavily for this system to work.

No way he won't address it imo.

He's used to having clyne work the right flank like a cyclone and an on fire Luke Shaw (pre-united neutering) tearing it up up and down the left flank.

That's the sort of level he's after.

I urge anyone who doesn't know what I'm getting at to go and watch some of s'ton's games from lasts season and then compare to the action we've seen on our flanks from our FBs, overall.

Not comparable in the least.

But it is now. :)

It just shows how quickly poch is strengthening key areas of our game.

It really is miraculous the speed in which he's done all this.
 
Top