Keane or Berbatov?

[Dougal]

So what is the reason Keane is infallible in yours and Jimbo's eyes?

Did I say that too? I really must see a doctor about these blackouts.

Loyalty? Well, Robbo signed a 7 year contract, and said he'd stay for life, but when he underperforms, he gets a lot of stick. Same sort of thing for Dawson.

And I don't agree with that stick either. The only players I have slated in the last couple of years have been Ghaly, Chimbonda and Keane, all for similar reasons. Other than that I support our players in good times and in bad.

 

[Flatters]

It was my answer to this question below.

So you don't think Keane is more passionate than our other players? For those of you that do, please answer the questions I asked Dougal.

 

[Dougal]

So you don't think Keane is more passionate than our other players? For those of you that do, please answer the questions I asked Dougal.

You can put me on record as saying I think Keane is as passionate about Spurs as Ledley King. Both players more so than any others in the squad.

 

[nicdic]

Why?

 

[TaoistMonkey]

yeah, keane is more passionate about the club than anyplayer we have.

he wants the club to do well. whether he's having a good game or bad game he's always trying :up:

 

[sundancer]

I love Keane and hope he stays for years, however they is no doubt in my eyes that Berby is the better player and could play in any team anywere.

 

[Dougal]

Why?

Because it is the impression I get. I haven't got round to asking the whole squad to rate their passion on a scale of 1 to 10.

 

[nicdic]

Let me know when you have :up:

 

[Dougal]

Let me know when you have :up:

You'll be the first to know :up:

 

[lennonslaces]

Keane for me, he's improved year on year considerably over the past four years. Berbatov looks looks more skill ful and has better ball control but I don't think he has the right attitude. Ifwe get 30 mill for him I would take it.

 

[jimbo]

Why?

I would say the same, that King and Keane are more passionate about the club than any other players. I can't give you any firm evidence to support my opinion, but have you never believed something without proof?

If you were asking 'Why are they more passionate?' then perhaps the answer would be as simple as them having been at the club longer, having seen more ups and downs along the way, so they have more emotion invested in it than players who haven't been around for the same length of time regardless of how long their contracts might be.

 

[milli.com]

This site is so biase I,m fed up.
It is obvious that berbatov is the better player thats why teams are willing to pay 25mill plus for him no team would pay that for keane.
The people who voted for keane are voting out of love,
The whole world other than them realise this thats why berba is sought after more than keane talk to any fan who surports another team and they all dream of having berba man u, chelsea, liverpool, even arsehole fans they dont dream of having keane. Keane played shit against bolton and all I see on this site is that berba played bad. Please I beg someone to give me keanes assists and goals scored in the Premier league since the january window closed.

 

[Dougal]

Please I beg someone to give me keanes assists and goals scored in the Premier league since the january window closed.

Any reason why you don't want them from before? Wouldn't want to be accused of bias now would you?

 

[nicdic]

I think that was one of his better spells just after Christmas wasn't it? I know he had a slow start, and is having a slow finish, but weren't November, December and January when he was on form?

 

[Dougal]

I think that was one of his better spells just after Christmas wasn't it? I know he had a slow start, and is having a slow finish, but weren't November, December and January when he was on form?

I believe he had a hot streak then although I don't have the stats infront of me.

 

[sloth]

Berbatov is on another level to Keane. Don't get me wrong Keane's very very good, but there's a reason that of our two strikers (both roughly the same age) all the interest is in one. Berbatov is a far superior player to Robbie Keane.

 

[DC_Boy]

Berbs by quite a distance - just look atheir market values -

he's better in the air - probably equal on the ground - has a bit more pace - much more strength - can play lone striker - can play with a small or big man - so he's way more versatile - and yes I do like RK - I think they're both Spurs legends after this season

 

[stevenqoz]

Ask the centre backs of the other 19 sides. Berbatov is in a different class......much like Cantana and Dalglish were.

 

[Flatters]

I just think it's unfair on many of our other players to suggest that they're not as passionate about the club as Robbie Keane, perhaps just because they have a different way of showing it, or don't really show it at all.

 

[Dougal]

I just think it's unfair on many of our other players to suggest that they're not as passionate about the club as Robbie Keane, perhaps just because they have a different way of showing it, or don't really show it at all.

Well I think it is unfair of you to expect me to believe they are as passionate if 'they have a different way of showing it, or don't really show it at all'. :razz: