- Jul 26, 2005
- 1,312
- 2,584
Thought someone else may have started one by now. As they haven't, here's my stab at it, be interesting to see other people's opinions..
Friedel. C. Started season very well then age caught up with him. A good pro though and good to have at the club
Loris. A-. Had to wait for his starts but he has proved to be a top buy and will get better. Minus for a few goals I felt he was at fault for, namely Everton, Liverpool away
Walker. B-. A poor first half of season but got somewhere near his best towards season end.
Dawson. B. top pro to stay and fight for place and crucial that he did with Kaboul out. Won't be 1st choice next season though.
Verts. A- a great debut season. Future Captain?.
BAE. D. Very poor this season, head not right for whatever reason.
Caulker. C+. Slightly disappointed in him based on his reviews from Swansea. Young so still has time, big season for him next year.
Naughts. D. Not a left back.
Gallas. C- Was inspirational for us once, season too far. Still can be many players who's scored for Chelsea, Arsenal and Spurs (and probably against them either)
Lennon. B. great first half of season. But got injured, wasn't the same after that. Sunderland goal was quality though.
Sandro. B+. Was best player till injury, missed him massively there after .
Parker. A for Effort, E for quality so I suppose that's a C overall.
Dembele. B. Had that run of games where when he played we never lost. Then he got injured playing on intl duty. Played better with on the team.
Hudd. C-. Did okay last few games but don't really see a future for him at club
Siggy. B-. A slow start but popped up with crucial goals, could prove useful squad member next season
Holtby. C. Don't think lived up to early hype. Has potential though.
Dempsey. B+. Marmite player but scored crucial goals and can't deny his effort.
Bale. A+. 4 awards, 30 goals, superstar Developing in front of our eyes. We are not a one man team, but he his by far our best player.
Defoe C. Was banging them in early season but 1 league goal since new year is very poor. Not top 4 quality IMHO
Ade. C- Absolute tosh till the Chelsea game but then proved there is a player there just we don't often see him.
Livermore. C. Squad player who gives his all just lacks quality
AVB. A-. Better than expected first season. Some strange decisions but then he is learning. Massive plus is that I think he is a fast learner. Definitely the right man for us. If backed by Levy, we can achieve something next season.
Friedel. C. Started season very well then age caught up with him. A good pro though and good to have at the club
Loris. A-. Had to wait for his starts but he has proved to be a top buy and will get better. Minus for a few goals I felt he was at fault for, namely Everton, Liverpool away
Walker. B-. A poor first half of season but got somewhere near his best towards season end.
Dawson. B. top pro to stay and fight for place and crucial that he did with Kaboul out. Won't be 1st choice next season though.
Verts. A- a great debut season. Future Captain?.
BAE. D. Very poor this season, head not right for whatever reason.
Caulker. C+. Slightly disappointed in him based on his reviews from Swansea. Young so still has time, big season for him next year.
Naughts. D. Not a left back.
Gallas. C- Was inspirational for us once, season too far. Still can be many players who's scored for Chelsea, Arsenal and Spurs (and probably against them either)
Lennon. B. great first half of season. But got injured, wasn't the same after that. Sunderland goal was quality though.
Sandro. B+. Was best player till injury, missed him massively there after .
Parker. A for Effort, E for quality so I suppose that's a C overall.
Dembele. B. Had that run of games where when he played we never lost. Then he got injured playing on intl duty. Played better with on the team.
Hudd. C-. Did okay last few games but don't really see a future for him at club
Siggy. B-. A slow start but popped up with crucial goals, could prove useful squad member next season
Holtby. C. Don't think lived up to early hype. Has potential though.
Dempsey. B+. Marmite player but scored crucial goals and can't deny his effort.
Bale. A+. 4 awards, 30 goals, superstar Developing in front of our eyes. We are not a one man team, but he his by far our best player.
Defoe C. Was banging them in early season but 1 league goal since new year is very poor. Not top 4 quality IMHO
Ade. C- Absolute tosh till the Chelsea game but then proved there is a player there just we don't often see him.
Livermore. C. Squad player who gives his all just lacks quality
AVB. A-. Better than expected first season. Some strange decisions but then he is learning. Massive plus is that I think he is a fast learner. Definitely the right man for us. If backed by Levy, we can achieve something next season.