- Dec 13, 2005
- 48,193
- 50,239
- Thread starter
- #10,961
The last two matches of 2023 and the first two of 2024 …
.
.
Controversial opinion incoming:Wish we were in for Olise
There was never enough contact for the player to go down like that. Referees are giving penalties for the slightest contact nowadays. I think the referee gave Villa this game. The second yellow for Berg was very soft. Yes he pulled his shirt but he didn’t really impede his forward motion. I didn’t even notice anything amiss in real time. Too many games are being decided by poor officiating both on the field and by VAR.They really do give penatly kicks far too easily.
Ruining the outcomes of games
100% agree. Part of the problem is that VAR virtually never overrule the referee’s decision to give a penalty regardless how “soft” it is.I continuously say this but they need to change what is and isnt a penalty.
Slight contact resulting in players flinging themselves down should not be a penalty.
A player can be inside the penalty area with almost zero chance of scoring in that position and be lightly touched resulting in a great chance to score.
That just is not in the spirit of the game
The question the referee should be asking is “does this justify a free shot at goal from 12 yards?” Too often the offense does not merit the punishment given.Yeah I think a penalty is such a big decision that the foul or handball should be blatant. Lo Celso and Kulu gave us great examples of a correct penalty decision, but something like this where the Villa player is looking for the penalty and there is no intent from the Burnley player to foul, it should not be a penalty.
They seemed to have fixed it when it comes to handballs but now they need to take a look at the types of fouls that can justify a penalty.
Today feels must win for the goons.Form table for the last 6 games. Couldn't get Arsenal, Utd or Newcastle in it because they're too far down.
View attachment 135883
Is it a foul is the only question to ask.The question the referee should be asking is “does this justify a free shot at goal from 12 yards?” Too often the offense does not merit the punishment given.
Jamie Redknapp saying Tomiyasu looked like a “fish up a tree”