Our first XI in comparison....

[Yiddo1982]

Debating with work colleagues over who has the best individuals:

Assuming everyone is fit and on top form...

This is maybe a little Spurs biased.

Man Utd

---------------GOMES--------------------

RAFAEL----VIDIC---KING-----EVRA

NANI-----MODRIC---FLETCHER—BALE

-----------------------VDV--------------

--------------ROONEY-----------------


Arsenal

---------------GOMES------------------

SAGNA—KING---DAWSON---CLICHY

NASRI----FABREGAS—MODRIC—BALE

------------------VDV--------------

------------------RVP-----------------

Chelsea

----------------CECH--------------------

CORLUKA—TERRY—KING—COLE

VDV--—MODRIC—ESSIEN—BALE

--------------LAMPARD-----------------------

----------------DROGBA-------------------


Overall

--------------------CECH---------------------

SAGNA---VIDIC----KING----COLE

NANI-----ESSIEN----MODRIC---BALE

--------------VDV-------------------------

----------------DROGBA--------------

Thoughts?

 

[WexfordTownSpur]

Debating with work colleagues over who has the best individuals:

Assuming everyone is fit and on top form...

This is maybe a little Spurs biased.

Man Utd

---------------GOMES--------------------

RAFAEL----VIDIC---KING-----EVRA

NANI-----MODRIC---FLETCHER—BALE

-----------------------VDV--------------

--------------ROONEY-----------------


Arsenal

---------------GOMES------------------

SAGNA—KING---DAWSON---CLICHY

NASRI----FABREGAS—MODRIC—BALE

------------------VDV--------------

------------------RVP-----------------

Chelsea

----------------CECH--------------------

CORLUKA—TERRY—KING—COLE

VDV--—MODRIC—ESSIEN—BALE

--------------LAMPARD-----------------------

----------------DROGBA-------------------


Overall

--------------------CECH---------------------

SAGNA---VIDIC----KING----COLE

NANI-----ESSIEN----MODRIC---BALE

--------------VDV-------------------------

----------------DROGBA--------------

Thoughts?

don't get this post at all?

 

[Vedi]

don't get this post at all?

Who of our players would be first-teamer for Man Utd, Arse, Chelsea etc.

 

[t79boy]

This thread made me laugh :-D

Saying that our and scums lovechild would give even barca a run for their money

 

[mil1lion]

Neither of those teams are worthy of having any of our players.

 

[Vedi]

Essien next to Modric looks tasty.

 

[danielneeds]

I think only the most biased Yid could put Modric in over Fabregas....

 

[brett.spurs]

Clichy is awful!

 

[thfc1989]

There is no way Dawson is better than Vermaelen

 

[tommyt]

This one will definitely generate discussion

 

[AngerManagement]

--------------------CECH---------------------

SAGNA---VIDIC----Terry----COLE

NANI-----ESSIEN----Fabregas---BALE

--------------Rooney-------------------------

----------------DROGBA--------------

 

[tooey]

..............Cech...............
Sagna..Vidic....King.....Evra
.....................................
Nasri...Essian...Fabregas..Bale
...............VDV.................
.............Drogba...............

That would be all kinds of awsome

 

[Vedi]

--------------------CECH---------------------

SAGNA---VIDIC----Terry----COLE

NANI-----ESSIEN----Fabregas---BALE

--------------Rooney-------------------------

----------------DROGBA--------------

Terry over a fully fit king?

Agree with the rest.

 

[AngerManagement]

Terry over a fully fit king?

Agree with the rest.

The point I was mostly trying to make is King is pretty much never fully fit and I think that has to be taken into account even in a pointless hypothetical situation like this.

Talent wise I feel King is the superior player but as an overall assest to a team King simply doesn't get enough game time so for that reason alone I picked Terry and probably would even have selected Ferdinand ahead of him.

 

[dynamoSpurs]

You agree with him omitting VDV?? You'd rather have Rooney or Nani over VDV?

Nutcases...

 

[AngerManagement]

You agree with him omitting VDV?? You'd rather have Rooney or Nani over VDV?

Nutcases...

I prefer VDV, in actual fact I would/should have selected him in right midfield.

BUt although I dislike Rooney and he has not been at his best recently over the last two seasons he has been won of the best players in the world so I think he is justified a place in that line up.

 

[Yiddo1982]

I think only the most biased Yid could put Modric in over Fabregas....

I slipped that one in :wink:

 

[guate]

Danielneeds, I normally agree with your comments however your preference for Fabregas over Modric surprises me as IMHO Luka is a far more industrious player and equally as skilfull, he just doesn't know it yet jejejejeje
Hopefully more playing time in the Champions will boost his confidence enough for him to fulfill his potential and hopefully have more cracks on goal, which, up to now, is where he let's himself down in any comparison with Fabregas

 

[brett.spurs]

GOMES
IVANOVIC RIO KING COLE
FABREGAS ESSIEN MODRIC
VDV DROGBA BALE

Subs: Cech, Sagna, Vidic, Nani, Scholes, Lampard, Rooney
​

 

[gregga]

Danielneeds, I normally agree with your comments however your preference for Fabregas over Modric surprises me as IMHO Luka is a far more industrious player and equally as skilfull, he just doesn't know it yet jejejejeje
Hopefully more playing time in the Champions will boost his confidence enough for him to fulfill his potential and hopefully have more cracks on goal, which, up to now, is where he let's himself down in any comparison with Fabregas

Blinkered.

Fabregas is both (amazingly) younger and better than Modric. He is, along with Essien, the best CM in the prem.