What's new

Poch: In or Out? - You CAN change your vote

Should Poch stay or go?

  • Stay

    Votes: 657 55.3%
  • Go

    Votes: 532 44.7%

  • Total voters
    1,189

Hakkz

Svensk hetsporre
Jul 6, 2012
8,196
17,270
Why is he so unfit? He was obviously OK before he came here. It must be the training right? We've heard before that it take players months to get Poch fit, is this what happens to them in-between? And if it is, why is he playing? Is this just Poch showing Levy why he needs players in early, or is he genuinely the best option at the moment?

But why do they need to get that fit anymore? We don't play intense pressing anymore anyway.
 

robin09

Well-Known Member
Jun 4, 2005
6,800
7,697
Better the fans want/demand success rather than being the type who just want to tell everyone to remember the 90s. We all remember the 90s, we were wank. We’re not so wank anymore, so standards have changed. The fanbase needs to get rid of its loser mentality, people are far too used to just accepting Tottenhams bullshit because it’s Tottenham, and the ones who demand we improve are ‘entitled’

You don't have to remember the 90s. Remember Ramos, AVB and Sherwood. 2013 isn't very long ago, is it?

Why have standards changed? Because Poch has steadily increased our expectations. Yet at the first sign of trouble, we want to get rid of that very same manager, so we can 'win trophies'.
The only teams who are going to win trophies for the next few years, are Manchester City and Liverpool. Everyone else is fighting for scraps. Nobody has the same level of investment available. There aren't handfuls of managers looking for work who could turn Spurs into the force that Poch has. We were 90 minutes away from winning the Champions League less than 6 months ago.

Tell me, who is available right now, to win us trophies, while working with the possibility that during any given window we may have zero net spend?


So yes, I think a lot of fans suffering from unrealistic expectations, is fair to call entitlement.
 

JCRD

Well-Known Member
Aug 10, 2018
19,153
30,013
To the people that want Poch to stay, why do you still want to give him more time to turn it around when he has already had ONE YEAR to turn it around and still hasn’t done it?

What exactly are you hoping and waiting for?

Did you not see tonight a squad that has stopped playing for the manager? After 30 minutes our players were dead on their feet. Our tactics were an abomination. In the second half we were an embarrassment and this has been the long line of poor performances.

Just what have you been watching for the last year?

Did you not see how flukey our CL run was? It was the same thing then. Look at how many goals we conceded to Ajax away and city away? Miraculously we managed to draw those games to get through but it was more of the same shambolic defending. We’ve been a piss poor side for quite some time. When was the last time you watched us play and thought we looked a convincing side?

The rot has been set in for ages now. Time to wake up.

Because youre assuming it is just his fault. It is a larger problem than just Poch. We are a window or two behind in my view. How can we sit here and just criticise Poch when in other threads we are slating the likes of CE and Aurier et al? If we are blaming both then Poch deserves the time and windows/cash to turn it around. If we are saying its all Poch's fault then the players shouldnt be blamed.

Im not burying my head in the sand her,e im conscious and aware the place has stunk for a year or so but the team has gone stale and the huge problem was not spending any money last year...
 

Tucker

Shitehawk
Jul 15, 2013
31,468
147,336
Tranmere don't play against Bayern Munich.

It was a freak game where everything Bayern did came off perfectly. We dominated for the first half an hour, then the frailties in the squad started to show. Combine that with Bayern's performance of a decade, and you can get a crazy result.

If we'd drawn the game last night, would there be a poll about 'Poch Out?' Would as many people have voted 'yes'?

Whenever sentiment can change from one extreme to the other on one single result, it's probably not a well thought through reaction.

The players are lacking confidence, there's uncertainty over the futures of a few starters, we didn't invest enough, and we need to try and rectify the squad problems in the next window. Until then, assuming we don't ship 4+ goals regularly, getting rid of Poch isn't going to help the club. Patience, and showing some loyalty is probably the best scenario right now.

Bayern are a good side, but they aren’t THAT much better than us. In fact it could be argued that given our resources we should at the very least be on a level with them.

This wasn’t Tranmere vs Spurs in the FA Cup third round, a complete mismatch in quality. This was two top level champions league clubs going toe to toe.

The way we capitulated was a complete humiliation and every change Poch made just made the situation worse. It’s indefensible.

If we’d got a draw people wouldn’t be angry, but we didn’t get a draw did we. We weren’t even fucking close. This wasn’t 3-2 or 2-1 or 1-0. This was a complete hiding. How anyone can defend Poch after that is baffling to me.
 

The Opinionated Lurker

Well-Known Member
Jun 9, 2019
720
2,554
You don't have to remember the 90s. Remember Ramos, AVB and Sherwood. 2013 isn't very long ago, is it?

Why have standards changed? Because Poch has steadily increased our expectations. Yet at the first sign of trouble, we want to get rid of that very same manager, so we can 'win trophies'.
The only teams who are going to win trophies for the next few years, are Manchester City and Liverpool. Everyone else is fighting for scraps. Nobody has the same level of investment available. There aren't handfuls of managers looking for work who could turn Spurs into the force that Poch has. We were 90 minutes away from winning the Champions League less than 6 months ago.

Tell me, who is available right now, to win us trophies, while working with the possibility that during any given window we may have zero net spend?


So yes, I think a lot of fans suffering from unrealistic expectations, is fair to call entitlement.
There’s a proven winner whoring himself and his knowledge out on Sky Sports who’d probably jump at seeing Levy ringing his phone. If I’m entitled for thinking we shouldn’t lose to Colchester or entitled for thinking that we shouldn’t ship 7 at home no matter what then I’m the most entitled fucker there is. Have you watched 2019? We’ve been awful for a while, the CL run was an absolute fluke it’s shameless that you’d even bring it up tbh. Poch was great and probably still could be. Just not here anymore. Remember, this is Tottenham Hotspur not Tottenham Pochspur
 

Wheeler Dealer

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2011
6,952
12,511
There was a bloody good reason Fergie was given all the time in the world and that was 38 trophies in a 26 year period V's Poch's Nil trophies and umpteen excuses!
The financial landscape was much more even during Fergie's early days. Unless there is a complete change of ownership, we're never going to compete for the best players when opposed by City, United, Chelsea and Liverpool.
 

Mr Pink

SC Supporter
Aug 25, 2010
55,243
100,560
Because youre assuming it is just his fault. It is a larger problem than just Poch. We are a window or two behind in my view. How can we sit here and just criticise Poch when in other threads we are slating the likes of CE and Aurier et al? If we are blaming both then Poch deserves the time and windows/cash to turn it around. If we are saying its all Poch's fault then the players shouldnt be blamed.

Im not burying my head in the sand her,e im conscious and aware the place has stunk for a year or so but the team has gone stale and the huge problem was not spending any money last year...

I agree, however, Poch should still be getting more from this group despite lack of investment in previous windows, and some disgruntled players.

He picks the team. Preparation and motivation is at his door.

Whilst there are most definitely mitigating factors to consider, they don't exonerate Poch of how poor we've been overall for the last 9 months.

That squad is packed with quality. And yes he has undoubtedly contributed to many players improving but we can't ignore the decline on the pitch for so long now.

We have to judge what we're seeing and the results.

And that's ultimately how levy will judge it.

There needs to be a very quick turn around imo.
 

Hugh DeMann

Well-Known Member
Dec 14, 2010
203
348
Unfortunately for Poch it is a lot easier to change manager than shift a load of players. Whether it is his making or not there is a sense of the squad not being as one. Unless there is a drastic change in the next game or two then I can see a change happening.

I would be absolutely gutted if this happens as I really rate Poch as a man and a coach.

Even if we get a new manager there are lots of squad issues to solve. He would need backing from Levy to be ruthless and splash the cash.
 

mike_l

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2005
5,171
3,676
Tranmere don't play against Bayern Munich.

It was a freak game where everything Bayern did came off perfectly. We dominated for the first half an hour, then the frailties in the squad started to show. Combine that with Bayern's performance of a decade, and you can get a crazy result.

If we'd drawn the game last night, would there be a poll about 'Poch Out?' Would as many people have voted 'yes'?

Whenever sentiment can change from one extreme to the other on one single result, it's probably not a well thought through reaction.

The players are lacking confidence, there's uncertainty over the futures of a few starters, we didn't invest enough, and we need to try and rectify the squad problems in the next window. Until then, assuming we don't ship 4+ goals regularly, getting rid of Poch isn't going to help the club. Patience, and showing some loyalty is probably the best scenario right now.
Yeah, of course all of the Poch out talk is based on this one result...
 

AllSeeingEye

YP Lee's Spiritual Guide
Apr 20, 2005
3,085
434
So far it's a stay, by Brexitesque margins. But if he loses at the weekend.... he'll be gone no matter what we say. Levy doesn't mess around.
 

Wheeler Dealer

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2011
6,952
12,511
Would want oil money on a season long loan, spend £2b win a couple of trophies, then back to how we normally operate
It will cost £2bn just to buy the club.. That's Levy's valuation. Add another £1bn to improve squad, then his takes it to £3bn. Not many people in the world with this sort of cash unfortunately.
 

JCRD

Well-Known Member
Aug 10, 2018
19,153
30,013
I agree, however, Poch should still be getting more from this group despite lack of investment in previous windows, and some disgruntled players.

He picks the team. Preparation and motivation is at his door.

Whilst there are most definitely mitigating factors to consider, they don't exonerate Poch of how poor we've been overall for the last 9 months.

That squad is packed with quality. And yes he has undoubtedly contributed to many players improving but we can't ignore the decline on the pitch for so long now.

We have to judge what we're seeing and the results.

And that's ultimately how levy will judge it.

There needs to be a very quick turn around imo.

The thing is the team is stale, we all knew it and we all know it to be true this season too. Should the players be doing better? damn straight and Poch is partly to blame but he deserves a chance to turn it around because we know what he is capable of. Levy is also to blame and as much as he had his hands full with the stadium i think he took his eye off the ball on the pitch.

For what its worth, I have a feeling this will only end one way and thats him leaving taking some time out and potentially revising his approach and methods, a bit like what Brendan Rodgers has done previously. We should have been progressing as much as Liverpool have - we started ahead of them. They are the benchmark for us when only a couple of years back we were the benchmark for them - how times have changed.
 

paulcumpstone

Well-Known Member
Jul 17, 2008
8,781
10,892
I'm poch out,
Reasons for me are this is a slow decline which shows no signs of stopping, the dull football we play 90% of the time. His insistence on playing athletes over any sort of pace/skill.
Lack of tactics, repeated awful subs. Poor formations.
Lack of integration of youth players, hes done more harm than good for the youth system we have.skipp is a prime example, should be playing football at some level or out on loan.
Lovely bloke and did wonders for the club when he joined but everything that made him a success when he joined he has abandoned, this includes the press and playing players on merit rather than reputation. Too many of our so called top players are far too comfortable.
 

Thewobbler

Well-Known Member
Oct 29, 2016
3,814
5,701
Because youre assuming it is just his fault. It is a larger problem than just Poch. We are a window or two behind in my view. How can we sit here and just criticise Poch when in other threads we are slating the likes of CE and Aurier et al? If we are blaming both then Poch deserves the time and windows/cash to turn it around. If we are saying its all Poch's fault then the players shouldnt be blamed.

Im not burying my head in the sand her,e im conscious and aware the place has stunk for a year or so but the team has gone stale and the huge problem was not spending any money last year...

Who is to blame for that though? Yes we probably didnt have the money to spend on a few players but im not going to entertain the idea that we couldnt have made one big signing to freshen the squad and give it a lift. We were close to grealish but they got new owners and the deal collapsed but we were so confident on that deal we didnt seem to bother looking elsewhere and it was to late after.
 

Spurrific

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2011
13,501
57,356
If he plays the diamond one more time he should be sacked before kick-off. Fucking idiotic formation that we don't have the players for. Don't understand how it got in his stubborn head.

The performances and results since January have been nothing short of dreadful. Part of the blame has to come from 3 windows of no reinforcements leading to a depleted, exhausted squad.

Yesterday was a freak result - but it's been coming. We could've been on the receive end of numerous poundings since the turn of the year.
 
Top