What's new

The Transfer Wishlist Thread

lincspurs

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2011
690
1,330
I agree, to be fair though our whole defensive setup is pretty poor for a team with Top 4 and CL ambitions. I think if we can tighten up everything in defence then he could become a good option in that role, especially if we can get him to cut out some of his errors.
That’s the crux though, he plays like 6 year old, diving in or chasing lost causes leaving him out of position & the team susceptible down the wing he’s supposed to be defending, IMO.
 

brendanb50

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2005
4,486
3,895
That’s the crux though, he plays like 6 year old, diving in or chasing lost causes leaving him out of position & the team susceptible down the wing he’s supposed to be defending, IMO.

Agreed - not sure it'll be 100% coached out of him but if he does stay, a stronger defensive unit (including a DM) would help make him more of a asset than a hindrance. As @brasil_spur said - our whole defensive unit needs tightening up, we've become very leaky and error-prone and if you want to compete for anything, this needs to be the foundation.
 

dtxspurs

Welcome to the Good Life
Dec 28, 2017
11,234
46,574
I agree, to be fair though our whole defensive setup is pretty poor for a team with Top 4 and CL ambitions. I think if we can tighten up everything in defence then he could become a good option in that role, especially if we can get him to cut out some of his errors.
He’s what 27? Not gonna happen.
 

Wig

Well-Known Member
May 23, 2018
2,823
11,123
Aurier can be a bit dozy at times, but the amount of flack he gets in here is over the top. I don't think some of you realise how much he contributes to the team stats, and until the break he was having a very decent season. Have a look at our players' stats from this season here:

Serge is equal 2nd for assists (4 just like Dele), number 1 for tackles with 74 tackles (almost double the tackles of 2nd place Davinson with 41), 3rd for clearances, and 1st for interceptions. When you see stats like this showing how he's contributing positively, cut the guy some slack and show him some support. There's a reason why he makes some errors and that's because he's more involved in the game than some other players who can go missing by comparison.
 

-Afri-Coy-

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2012
5,853
18,611
Aurier can be a bit dozy at times, but the amount of flack he gets in here is over the top. I don't think some of you realise how much he contributes to the team stats, and until the break he was having a very decent season. Have a look at our players' stats from this season here:

Serge is equal 2nd for assists (4 just like Dele), number 1 for tackles with 74 tackles (almost double the tackles of 2nd place Davinson with 41), 3rd for clearances, and 1st for interceptions. When you see stats like this showing how he's contributing positively, cut the guy some slack and show him some support. There's a reason why he makes some errors and that's because he's more involved in the game than some other players who can go missing by comparison.

Age old thing, you can do 1000 good things but people will remember the 1 time you fucked up over those good things.

Unfortunately this is how most people's minds work.
 

Wig

Well-Known Member
May 23, 2018
2,823
11,123
And in reality he's not that good offensively. Replacing him should be our priority.
If we're singling out a priority, personally I believe it's more of a priority to get a top-class DM... Someone to shield the defence and to give a springboard to the more attacking midfielders (Ndombele, Lo Celso etc.) to play to their strengths. Secondary priority is another striker to compete/backup Kane.
 

mr ashley

Well-Known Member
Jan 27, 2011
3,133
8,535
If we're singling out a priority, personally I believe it's more of a priority to get a top-class DM... Someone to shield the defence and to give a springboard to the more attacking midfielders (Ndombele, Lo Celso etc.) to play to their strengths. Secondary priority is another striker to compete/backup Kane.
That’s the predicament we’re in right now. We’ve got three genuine priority areas that need addressing. Two of them are linked and affect our ability to defend. The other is about protecting our talisman. With a shrinking budget and a notoriously tight fisted chairman it doesn’t bode well.
Aurier is a good attacking right back, but for all the tackles he’s won, he’s cost goals by diving in or being out of position. He seems to play on instinct too much, and is too much of a risk taker.
If we could solve one or other of the problems with coaching (let’s say foyth rb and winks cdm) that could work. It would leave money for osimhen or odsonne.
 

brasil_spur

SC Supporter
Aug 25, 2006
12,693
16,781
He’s what 27? Not gonna happen.

I disagree with this somewhat. This is the first season he's had in the PL with a decent number of games under his belt and has had to contend with two different managers during this time.

If you look at Van Dijk, who is arguably the best defender in the world right now (top 5 for sure). He was 26 when he joined Liverpool and whilst he was the Saints captain, he has definitely improved a lot since moving to Liverpool.

I'm not saying it's a direct comparison, but for me Aurier has shown enough to suggest that with a consistent manager, a consistent run of games and some additional support across our defense he might be a decent player for us in the coming season.
 

Hoopspur

You have insufficient privileges to reply here!
Jun 28, 2012
6,332
9,703
I disagree with this somewhat. This is the first season he's had in the PL with a decent number of games under his belt and has had to contend with two different managers during this time.

If you look at Van Dijk, who is arguably the best defender in the world right now (top 5 for sure). He was 26 when he joined Liverpool and whilst he was the Saints captain, he has definitely improved a lot since moving to Liverpool.

I'm not saying it's a direct comparison, but for me Aurier has shown enough to suggest that with a consistent manager, a consistent run of games and some additional support across our defense he might be a decent player for us in the coming season.

Can I remind you that someone who wasn't the finished article cost £70m!! :eek: Jeez, what would a finished one cost? That transfer has skewed everything completely. Mind you, I did kind of know he was good at Saints and I'm certainly no expert.
 

brasil_spur

SC Supporter
Aug 25, 2006
12,693
16,781
Can I remind you that someone who wasn't the finished article cost £70m!! :eek: Jeez, what would a finished one cost? That transfer has skewed everything completely. Mind you, I did kind of know he was good at Saints and I'm certainly no expert.

Yes it's nuts, one of the silver linings from this whole Corona situation might be that the stupid transfer fees become a thing of the past... but i reckon that's wishful thinking and we'll be back where we were in a couple of seasons time.
 

dtxspurs

Welcome to the Good Life
Dec 28, 2017
11,234
46,574
Aurier can be a bit dozy at times, but the amount of flack he gets in here is over the top. I don't think some of you realise how much he contributes to the team stats, and until the break he was having a very decent season. Have a look at our players' stats from this season here:

Serge is equal 2nd for assists (4 just like Dele), number 1 for tackles with 74 tackles (almost double the tackles of 2nd place Davinson with 41), 3rd for clearances, and 1st for interceptions. When you see stats like this showing how he's contributing positively, cut the guy some slack and show him some support. There's a reason why he makes some errors and that's because he's more involved in the game than some other players who can go missing by comparison.
The reason he is more error prone is because he falls asleep at the wheel constantly. Sure he's decent on the offensive end but he's not much better than Trippier defensively. He's constantly trailing the play, diving in, standing in no man's land, etc. He's a liability at the back, I don't know how that could be debated. RB & DM are priority 1A & 1B for me.

I'd argue the reason his defensive stats are so high is because teams target him. All you really need to do is ask yourself which other top teams would want him as there starter? ManU, City, Chelsea, Leicester, Wolves, Liverpool all no's. Maybe Arsenal or Everton?
 

TEESSIDE1

Married, new job and Spurs on the up!
Jul 3, 2006
15,170
18,943
The reason he is more error prone is because he falls asleep at the wheel constantly. Sure he's decent on the offensive end but he's not much better than Trippier defensively. He's constantly trailing the play, diving in, standing in no man's land, etc. He's a liability at the back, I don't know how that could be debated. RB & DM are priority 1A & 1B for me.

I'd argue the reason his defensive stats are so high is because teams target him. All you really need to do is ask yourself which other top teams would want him as there starter? ManU, City, Chelsea, Leicester, Wolves, Liverpool. Maybe Arsenal or Everton?

4 assists? Considering we’re heavily reliant on our full backs for width and putting the ball into the box... 4 assists is nothing to write home about, especially when the majority our attacking width goes through Aurier. I watch every Spurs match (tv/app) and the amount of times he puts in aimless crosses/straight at the keeper is ridiculous.

Defensively he’s a shambles.
 

Cochise

Well-Known Member
Aug 8, 2019
4,854
12,666
Personally, I want a new first choice RB. Aurier strings me along with 3-4 good performances and then has a shocker or makes a stupid mistake leading to a goal. I do think that he is over criticised at times, but that shouldn't detract from the honest criticism of his poor performances.
 

spursfan77

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2005
46,680
104,957
Personally, I want a new first choice RB. Aurier strings me along with 3-4 good performances and then has a shocker or makes a stupid mistake leading to a goal. I do think that he is over criticised at times, but that shouldn't detract from the honest criticism of his poor performances.

I agree. I think we'd be a lot more solid with a new right back.
 

Cochise

Well-Known Member
Aug 8, 2019
4,854
12,666
With that said, I would still prioritise a DM and CB over a new RB. I think building a strong spine is massively important and those two positions are bigger issues.
 

pedrodelawasp

Morton season ticket holder, Spurs fan from afar
Jan 14, 2019
1,447
2,450
With that said, I would still prioritise a DM and CB over a new RB. I think building a strong spine is massively important and those two positions are bigger issues.

Probably with you as far as DM as we lack a real specialist there. CB may be one Of the more stacked areas of the squad, though (Alderweireld, Sanchez, Dier, Foyth, Tanganga, [Vertonghen, for now] plus Davies able to play there).

in order of urgency I’d likely go:

1) DM. Someone like Zakaria who’s quick, strong, tall and energetic. Tackles, intercepts, good with the ball at his feet and can drop in between the CBs comfortably to form a 3 if that’s the tactic.

2) Fullback. Ideally someone who’s adept/comfortable on either side. Hakimi would be a dream signing (that won’t happen). Atal perhaps?

3) Striker/Forward. If you could ‘build your ideal striker’ to add to our squad they’d have pace and the ability to play off the flanks or in the middle, alongside or deputising for Kane, but also some of the physical strength and hold up play we looked to get out of Llorente. Must loads of bargains out there that fit that bill!

4) CB. An upgrade if one’s available and the money’s right, or a younger prospect to grow in to peak Vertonghen Mk2?

3&4 could be reversed, mind you. I’m swithering.
 

Ron Burgundy

SC Supporter
Jun 19, 2008
7,736
23,410
Probably with you as far as DM as we lack a real specialist there. CB may be one Of the more stacked areas of the squad, though (Alderweireld, Sanchez, Dier, Foyth, Tanganga, [Vertonghen, for now] plus Davies able to play there).

in order of urgency I’d likely go:

1) DM. Someone like Zakaria who’s quick, strong, tall and energetic. Tackles, intercepts, good with the ball at his feet and can drop in between the CBs comfortably to form a 3 if that’s the tactic.

2) Fullback. Ideally someone who’s adept/comfortable on either side. Hakimi would be a dream signing (that won’t happen). Atal perhaps?

3) Striker/Forward. If you could ‘build your ideal striker’ to add to our squad they’d have pace and the ability to play off the flanks or in the middle, alongside or deputising for Kane, but also some of the physical strength and hold up play we looked to get out of Llorente. Must loads of bargains out there that fit that bill!

4) CB. An upgrade if one’s available and the money’s right, or a younger prospect to grow in to peak Vertonghen Mk2?

3&4 could be reversed, mind you. I’m swithering.

I think this is broadly right. Otherwise you should be able to get quite a lot out of the existing squad...though I still have massive question marks about Mou
 

Japhet

Well-Known Member
Aug 30, 2010
19,271
57,611
I wish we could get Campos in. I'd be much happier giving him a transfer budget than handing it to Mourinho or letting Levy muck deals up.
 

Gbspurs

Gatekeeper for debates, King of the plonkers
Jan 27, 2011
26,970
61,859
4 assists? Considering we’re heavily reliant on our full backs for width and putting the ball into the box... 4 assists is nothing to write home about, especially when the majority our attacking width goes through Aurier. I watch every Spurs match (tv/app) and the amount of times he puts in aimless crosses/straight at the keeper is ridiculous.

Defensively he’s a shambles.

4 assists is definitely alright for a RB. Not his fault the LB isn't providing anthing. How many assists did Trippier or Walker get for us at their peak?
 
Top