What's new

Post Europa Cup Big Ange Poll

Should Ange Postecoglou stay or go?

  • Stay

    Votes: 576 57.8%
  • Go with his head held high

    Votes: 421 42.2%

  • Total voters
    997
Status
Not open for further replies.

XIIIMPC

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2010
500
1,200
Stay - not because he won the Europa, but because having listened to him explain the way he won it, and the knock on the the league, makes sense!

I think you have a point here particularly. I believe he probably did go somewhat against the higher-ups to significantly prioritise the Europa and his gamble paid off. And frankly it's about time we did that. I'm not sure this heavy league prioritisation is a Levy/whoever edict but it has sure seemed that way.

We could, and maybe should, have won - or done much better in - the Europa on multiple occasions in the last 20ish years. We had the team for it, a team that matched anyone in the competition. The one that infuriates me most is Redknapp functionally throwing the tie against Shakhtar in 2009, but there were many other times. Our piss-weak effort in the Conference League I even found absurd. That was our tournament for the taking and we functionally chose not to even try (no, the Rennes forfeit isn't an excuse because it shouldn't have mattered). Fucking win stuff. There is no tournament (that we would realistically be in) that we are too big to win, too big to bother with. And that's been the attitude from more than a few managers down the years, even including Pochettino, who played down the importance of winning the FA Cup in a press conference before an FA Cup tie. And in hindsight, Poch, was that pathetic elimination to Gent in 2016 worth finishing 3rd? Did we materially gain anything from that defeat? Hard to say.

I'm not necessarily saying Ange In, I'm on the fence, but on this I'm aligned with him. It was a huge gamble and it paid off for the club, but maybe it won't for him individually.
 
Last edited:

brisbanespur

Well-Known Member
Aug 17, 2006
162
548
I think he has earned the right to go again, but I am very concerned that losing is a habit like winning can be one as well. All though Poch’s results were never as bad as what we have witnessed this season, it’s a similar scenario. Worsen results leading to a European final, next season following a similar level of performance in the league, hello new manager sometime in Oct
 

chilespurs

Active Member
Aug 2, 2010
127
152
I think you have a point here particularly. I believe he probably did go somewhat against the higher-ups to significantly prioritise the Europa and his gamble paid off. And frankly it's about time we did that. I'm not sure this heavy league prioritisation is a Levy/whoever edict but it has sure seemed that way.

We could, and maybe should, have won - or done much better in - the Europa on multiple occasions in the last 20ish years. We had the team for it, a team that matched anyone in the competition. The one that infuriates me most is Redknapp functionally throwing the tie against Shakhtar in 2009, but there were many other times. Our piss-weak effort in the Conference League I even found absurd. That was our tournament for the taking and we functionally chose not to even try (no, the Rennes forfeit isn't an excuse because it shouldn't have mattered). Fucking win stuff. There is no tournament (that we would realistically be in) that we are too big to win, too big to bother with. And that's been the attitude from more than a few managers down the years, even including Pochettino, who played down the importance of winning the FA Cup in a press conference before an FA Cup tie. And in hindsight, Poch, was that pathetic elimination to Gent in 2016 worth finishing 3rd? Did we materially gain anything from that defeat? Hard to say.

I'm not necessarily saying Ange In, I'm on the fence, but on this I'm aligned with him. It was a huge gamble and it paid off for the club, but maybe it won't for him individually.
The difference this time, is that wining it has given us champions league, so maybe Levy not only accepted Ange's position but in fact encouraged it.
 

Armstrong_11

Spurs makes me happy, you... not so much :)
Aug 3, 2011
8,817
19,964
Frankly.... I think it's time for a change. I think it's a good way to end, a really good memory.

He and the whole teams are legends.
 

Timbo Tottenham

Well-Known Member
May 7, 2006
3,633
10,366
I was late to the Ange Out party as it took me a while to be convinced, winning on Wednesday, as glorious as it was, didn’t change my mind back.

I went to the game yesterday and the atmosphere in and around the ground was immense, until we played football. I was on such a high for days until I left the ground yesterday and felt totally deflated.
 

XIIIMPC

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2010
500
1,200
The difference this time, is that wining it has given us champions league, so maybe Levy not only accepted Ange's position but in fact encouraged it.

Yeah, that's very possible. If he did then it's more likely he'll stay.
 

freeeki

Arsehole.
Aug 5, 2008
12,656
76,509
I don't get where this "he went against the board to prioritise the Europa League" narrative has come from.

Can someone point me to some examples of games this season where he didn't play the strongest XI available to him, aside from perhaps just before the semi final?

I can't think of any.

Which means he must have put his strongest XI out in the league, but told the lads to go out and lose.

It's just more of the same nonsense from a small, shrill crowd who have an excuse for absolutely everything.
 

muppetman

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2011
13,930
41,367
I don't get where this "he went against the board to prioritise the Europa League" narrative has come from.

Can someone point me to some examples of games this season where he didn't play the strongest XI available to him, aside from perhaps just before the semi final?

I can't think of any.

Which means he must have put his strongest XI out in the league, but told the lads to go out and lose.

It's just more of the same nonsense from a small, shrill crowd who have an excuse for absolutely everything.
Small, shrill crowd?

Or it could just be people that disagree with you! 🤣🤣🤣
 

freeeki

Arsehole.
Aug 5, 2008
12,656
76,509
Small, shrill crowd?

Or it could just be people that disagree with you! 🤣🤣🤣

No.

I think most people are able to look at things with a bit of nuance, and come to a conclusion on balance.

Then there are others - a small, shrill crowd - who have found excuses for every defeat and every woeful performance this season. And there have been a lot of them.
 

muppetman

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2011
13,930
41,367
No.

I think most people are able to look at things with a bit of nuance, and come to a conclusion on balance.

Then there are others - a small, shrill crowd - who have found excuses for every defeat and every woeful performance this season. And there have been a lot of them.
That generally not what I've seen. 🤷‍♂️
 

RJR1949

Well-Known Member
Jan 31, 2013
1,405
7,820
No head coach should be fired until Levy has gone? They all have complete immunity?
…. and quite what do you think could cause Levy to go?

He’s the second largest shareholder and has the complete confidence of the largest shareholder. At some point he’ll want to realise the value of his investment but that’s not going to happen any time soon.
 

Reprobate

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2014
139
283
I don't get where this "he went against the board to prioritise the Europa League" narrative has come from.

Can someone point me to some examples of games this season where he didn't play the strongest XI available to him, aside from perhaps just before the semi final?

I can't think of any.

Which means he must have put his strongest XI out in the league, but told the lads to go out and lose.

It's just more of the same nonsense from a small, shrill crowd who have an excuse for absolutely everything.

That's been on my mind too. Happy to accept there is some truth in deprioritising the league games more recently. But the post-final narrative now seems to be we threw the league months ago. Not sure I believe that.

I decided not to judge yesterday's game since the team had been on a bender. But it was still hard not to come away from the game feeling that performance is just the same as what we've seen for half a season or more.
 

RJR1949

Well-Known Member
Jan 31, 2013
1,405
7,820
I was late to the Ange Out party as it took me a while to be convinced, winning on Wednesday, as glorious as it was, didn’t change my mind back.

I went to the game yesterday and the atmosphere in and around the ground was immense, until we played football. I was on such a high for days until I left the ground yesterday and felt totally deflated.

Quite right.

It’s hard to be Ange in when you have suffered through so many games as yesterday. We were completely outplayed and out worked by Brighton, even though, man for man, we have a stronger squad.
 

Gareth88

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2017
4,788
7,061
I have been flip flopping the last few days but I can't see him remaining in charge but fear this will leave alot of our players sour over him being replaced.
 

Hoopspur

You have insufficient privileges to reply here!
Jun 28, 2012
6,419
9,857
No.

I think most people are able to look at things with a bit of nuance, and come to a conclusion on balance.

Then there are others - a small, shrill crowd - who have found excuses for every defeat and every woeful performance this season. And there have been a lot of them.
That’s a large, small shrill crowd then? 😜
 

Reprobate

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2014
139
283
Every time I think about this though actually, I come back to sacking Ange now would be a message to future managers that winning cups isn't good enough, you have to aim for top 4.

I hate the idea of going back to 4th place being our aspirations. I want this club to consider winning trophies the most important thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top