Pochettino or Mourinho?

[riggi]

As a fan, Ramos gave some amazing experiences at WHL

Even as the opposing manager, the atmosphere against Seville is probably one of the best I have experienced

That 5-1 win against Arsenal probably the most satisfying win as a spurs fan. Still remember going mental, I was floating by the end lol

Unreal nights. Won’t happen again I fear.

 

[SpunkyBackpack]

Andy Sinton or Stephen Clemence?

Finally this thread has a topic worth debating. Andy Sinton of course.

 

[Everlasting Seconds]

Villas-Boas.

 

[Metalhead]

Knowing what we now know who would you prefer to be in charge now?
Poch or Jose?

You must have been bored.

 

[Gassin's finest]

Jol.

 

[CantSmileWithoutYou]

Knowing what we now know who would you prefer to be in charge now?
Poch or Jose?

Oh fuck off

just a discussion point no need to be a dick

I wasn't the dick, dondo.

Opening a wanky titled, leading thread, literally 2 minutes after the final whistle after a defeat vs Liverpool, is being dickish.

This could quite easily have been discussed in the Mourinho thread.

Don't be so hasty to be in the limelight woth youre own shiny thread next time.

 

[Nebby]

I’ll play: Jose.

If he’s given a decent run, he will produce a team that wins something.

 

[dondo]

I wasn't the dick, dondo.

Opening a wanky titled, leading thread, literally 2 minutes after the final whistle after a defeat vs Liverpool, is being dickish.

This could quite easily have been discussed in the Mourinho thread.

Don't be so hasty to be in the limelight woth youre own shiny thread next time.

You have made your points and that’s fair enough but your Initial response telling me to F off is being a dick actually

 

[CantSmileWithoutYou]

You have made your points and that’s fair enough but your Initial response telling me to F off is being a dick actually

And I explained why in my previous answer.

 

[Gareth88]

Santini anyone???

 

[dondo]

You must have been bored.

Been thinking about it the last few weeks. Mourinho has come to the conclusion Pochettino did imo, that this squad needs a big overhaul and that things are not going to drastically improve under him. I thought our defence would have improved but it’s got worse if anything.
It comes down to who we want to rebuild the side I suppose.
Was a stupid thread to start in hindsight straight after the match and probably wouldn’t have done so if didn’t spend the pre match in the pub ?

 

[Shadydan]

Knowing what we now know who would you prefer to be in charge now?
Poch or Jose?

Hmmm not one of your finest moments on here. ?

 

[Metalhead]

Been thinking about it the last few weeks. Mourinho has come to the conclusion Pochettino did imo, that this squad needs a big overhaul and that things are not going to drastically improve under him. I thought our defence would have improved but it’s got worse if anything.
It comes down to who we want to rebuild the side I suppose.
Was a stupid thread to start in hindsight straight after the match and probably wouldn’t have done so if didn’t spend the pre match in the pub ?

No harm done but of course you're right - it's going to be a big endeavour and it's going to take a while I reckon.

 

[dontcallme]

Your missing my point. It’s not about time it’s about the players,we need a complete overhaul and should overseeing the overhaul.
Many posters on here, you included yourself iirc were very critical of Pochettino in his later days
But since Mourinho has taken over we have very similar problems

I think this is the problem with the thread. Jose has been here 6 weeks. No time at all to make major changes.

It feels like you're pro-Poch and not a fan of Jose so you have waited for us to lose to start the debate.

The debate has been done to death in Poch and Mourinho threads so no need for yet another thread discussing it.

 

[dondo]

I think this is the problem with the thread. Jose has been here 6 weeks. No time at all to make major changes.

It feels like you're pro-Poch and not a fan of Jose so you have waited for us to lose to start the debate.

The debate has been done to death in Poch and Mourinho threads so no need for yet another thread discussing it.

I didn’t want Pochettino to go but if the reports of him losing the dressing room were true he had to I suppose.
I was very happy when we appointed Jose but now I’m a little worried about recent games and performances.
It’s early days and he must be given time and money. I wouldn’t expect to see a proper Mourinho type team till next season at the earliest

 

[Dougal]

I think this is the problem with the thread. Jose has been here 6 weeks. No time at all to make major changes.

It feels like you're pro-Poch and not a fan of Jose so you have waited for us to lose to start the debate.

The debate has been done to death in Poch and Mourinho threads so no need for yet another thread discussing it.

I didn’t wait for us to lose. I expected to lose because there are bigger problems than who the manager is. I’m not a fan of Mourinho, plain and simple. I can’t just become one, I really dislike the guy. The only thing I will wait for is the trophies. The ones we will win. Because Mourinho guarantees trophies so all is well.

 

[Gb160]

I really dislike the guy.

How well do you know him?

 

[Gb160]

I didn’t want Pochettino to go but if the reports of him losing the dressing room were true he had to I suppose.
I was very happy when we appointed Jose but now I’m a little worried about recent games and performances.
It’s early days and he must be given time and money. I wouldn’t expect to see a proper Mourinho type team till next season at the earliest

I think Levy took the difficult but sensible choice.
If you're going to rebuild then do you leave that to a guy who has won the fucking lot, or a guy who hasn't even won a raffle?

 

[dontcallme]

I didn’t wait for us to lose. I expected to lose because there are bigger problems than who the manager is. I’m not a fan of Mourinho, plain and simple. I can’t just become one, I really dislike the guy. The only thing I will wait for is the trophies. The ones we will win. Because Mourinho guarantees trophies so all is well.

You didn't start the thread so wasn't referring to you as you didn't start the thread.

I understand some don't like Jose and some wanted Poch to be given time to rebuild. As it appears he lost the dressing room I disagree Poch was the man for the rebuild but no problem with people having the opposite view.

The thread was poorly timed and a little unnecessary but no real issue.

 

[midge]

Knowing what we now know who would you prefer to be in charge now?
Poch or Jose?

We would need to list out what do we now know to be able to make an informed decision

What do we know now that we didnt know then...i tried listing some out

Would Toby have sign ? Poch (no) Jose (yes)
Would KPW have more playing time ? Poch (no) Jose (no)
Would Winks have more playing time? Poch (yes) Jose (no)
Would Dier have more playing time? Poch (no) Jose (yes)
Would Japhet played against Liverpool ? Poch (guessing it would be no) Jose (yes)
Would Kane have played against Bayern ? Poch (guessing it would be yes) Jose (no)
Would Kane get injured if Poch was manager? Poch(no idea) Jose (yes)
Would Sissoko get injured if Poch was manager? Poch(no idea) Jose (yes)
Would Moura get more playing time ? Poch (no) Jose (yes)
Would Skipp get more playing time? Poch (yes) Jose (no)
Would Ali have been playing like crap? Poch (yes) Jose ( neither i guess , played well for first few games sucked for the rest)
Would Son have gotten a red card? Poch (no idea) Jose (yes)
Would we more or less the point total if Poch was in charge of the games Jose was incharged of? Poch (less, personal opinion)
Would we have beaten Liverpool? Poch (no) Jose (no)
Would our football have been more sexy ? Poch (no) Jose (no)
Would Eriksen sign the contract? Poch (no) Jose (yes)


Think the list can go on a fair bit. Looking at the list, dont really see much difference but like some said Jose had 6 weeks Poch had a pre season so the question cannot really be answered in a logical way.