We didn't appeal Naughton's red card

[THFCSPURS19]

Ben Rumsby ‏@ben_rumsby 12h
One small piece of news to slip under the radar is that #thfc did NOT appeal Naughton red v #whufc - put off by FA's 'obvious error' rule.


"Obvious error" rule- What the fuck is that...?

 

[chrissivad]

not a surprise we didnt appeal.

Not sure it would have been over turned and we would lose are only RB at the moment for another game... Vs Liverpool

 

[wallyjakeman]

"Obvious error" is a bit harsh. He's a decent back up for Walker.

 

[Everlasting Seconds]

Maybe it is not obvious that the referee made a mistake?

 

[guiltyparty]

Ben Rumsby ‏@ben_rumsby 12h
One small piece of news to slip under the radar is that #thfc did NOT appeal Naughton red v #whufc - put off by FA's 'obvious error' rule.


"Obvious error" rule- What the fuck is that...?

Only thing I could find on it: http://www.danielgeey.com/andy-carroll-and-the-fa-disciplinary-appeal-procedures/

Interesting read

 

[THFCSPURS19]

So how many games is he suspended for?

 

[carpediem991]

So how long is the ban? 1, 2 or 3 games? Would mean Dier on the right and Kabs with Verty at CB.

As long they are fit...

 

[chrissivad]

will just be 1 game

 

[Phantom]

I thought it was a fairly clear a mistake, too many things involved for it to have been a clear red. The only person I have seen agree with the ref has been Rudd Gulllit.

Was it intentional? I don't think anyone can clearly say it was, he was so close to the ball as it was struck. I am not even 100% he has his eyes on the ball as it happens. That is before you can even answer if it was on target. Also it is a fair assumption that Kyle is not going to be better at stopping a shot with his hands than a professional goalie who is standing directly behind him and will have more time to react!

But I guess in a world where Stevie G can attack someone be caught on CCTV doing so, suggest it was self defence and get away with it.... then we cant be sure of anything!

 

[SlickMongoose]

You're only going to get a red for handball overturned if the ball didn't hit his arm. If the ball did hit his arm, it's down to the ref's judgement, and will never be overturned.

 

[ravo]

will just be 1 game

Thanks. For some reason I always thought a straight red was three games regardless. Are there certain circumstances (aside fron Naughton's) where a straight red is only one game? Thanks

 

[theShiznit]

No way on earth could that be classed as a frivolous appeal. Can only think FA warned us not to so as not to make their shit officials look bad too early on in the season...

 

[parklane1]

not a surprise we didnt appeal.

Not sure it would have been over turned and we would lose are only RB at the moment for another game... Vs Liverpool

I agree, it would have been a pointless appeal.

 

[SlickMongoose]

Thanks. For some reason I always thought a straight red was three games regardless. Are there certain circumstances (aside fron Naughton's) where a straight red is only one game? Thanks

Only 1 game if it's for denying a goalscoring opportunity (as in this case). 3 games for violent conduct.

 

[chrissivad]

Thanks. For some reason I always thought a straight red was three games regardless. Are there certain circumstances (aside fron Naughton's) where a straight red is only one game? Thanks

I think a red card for denying a goal scoring chance is the only one (or that i can think of)

Violent conduct or serious foul play i think are 3

 

[theShiznit]

Only 1 game if it's for denying a goalscoring opportunity (as in this case). 3 games for violent conduct.

I think a red can be 1 2 3 or 4 match ban depending on circumstances. 1 for 2 yellows and professional fouls. 2 for offensive, insulting or abusive language or gestures 3 for dangerous/reckless play or violent conduct and 4 for amassing three? or more? Reds in a season.

 

[Geyzer Soze]

So are we looking at Kaboul at right back for the next game?

 

[cwy21]

It was a harsh red but it was defensible in the laws of the game. For that reason, it makes sense they didn't appeal.

 

[Syn_13]

So are we looking at Kaboul at right back for the next game?

I'm sure it will be Dier.

 

[Geyzer Soze]

I'm sure it will be Dier.

Oh yeah of course. Mildly panicked there!